Test Drive Report: Renault Twingo Z.E.: Found Its True Self Electrically
Why not like this from the start - this question arises after the first test drive in the new Renault Twingo Z.E., which will soon be called Twingo Electric. Instead of the noisy, jerky, and thermally problematic combustion engine, a 60 kW three-phase synchronous motor now works in the rear - and in a completely different manner: totally silent. Unfortunately, the compact electric unit, which directly drives the rear wheels and supplies a lively 160 Nm of torque from a standstill, did not make the trunk any larger. Where other small cars still offer a second level, the Twingo remains with a relatively flat, more or less storage space for two or three suitcases or crates of drinks. Officially, it should be 219 liters, which increases to 980 liters when the rear seats are folded down.
This is acceptable for a city car that is only 3.61 meters long. A Fiat 500e of the same length or a Mini Cooper SE, which is 20 centimeters longer, doesn't hold any more either. Those who hoped that there might be a "frunk" in the front for additional storage space will also be disappointed: The "hood" only opens to a narrow maintenance compartment for washer fluid and operating fluids after a fiddly unlocking process with the still central analog key.
Contrast: Modern Drive, Retro Key Turn
To close the chapter on space: Like its combustion engine counterpart, the Twingo can, in a pinch, accommodate four adults on short trips, but definitely offers space for two adults and two children. The headroom is more generous than the legroom. Additionally, the front seats are quite comfortable for adults, while the rear seats feel more like a bench. When you sit in the cockpit, dominated by a monochrome display with a semi-circular speedometer, you instinctively look for the start button. Then you find the "ignition lock," which is now devoid of its original function because nothing needs igniting. Instead, the electric motor is started with an anachronistic turn of the key, without making any noise. The driving mode is selected with the somewhat bulky gear lever in the center console. And off you go on the first drive.
Quick to Speed: The Twingo sprints off well
And how! From 0 to 50 km/h, the Twingo shoots off like a little bouncy ball. Above that, the thrust decreases slightly, and it takes 12 seconds to reach 100 km/h. But all that is irrelevant because you can leave any large SUV behind at the traffic lights and then cruise comfortably. If you overdo it in the curve, the very cautious ESP will brake early, as the wheels would otherwise start to search for grip when accelerating out. Only at walking speed does the Twingo emit the usual Z.E. sound, also for external warning.
Otherwise, the newly developed E-engine with the code R80, which does not come from the Zoe, exhibits excellent manners. Even when recuperating, no whining reaches the driver’s ear. A true relief compared to the otherwise roaring combustion engine in the rear. The generator output is modifiable in three stages, and the firmest stage allows for extensive one-pedal operation up to the last tick before coming to a stop, which is very convenient. The same goes for starting off, as the Twingo crawls smoothly even on inclines as soon as you release the brake.
The whole vehicle feels somehow more "solid"
Compared to the combustion engine model, aside from the subjectively higher torsional stiffness and more solid damping, the improved road handling is also noticeable: The Twingo as an electric vehicle feels less susceptible to crosswinds on the highway, and thanks to decent suspension, cruise control, and an acoustic lane assistant, it is quite suitable for long-distance travel. On country roads, it sweeps through curves much more stiffly thanks to the lower center of gravity. The steering conveys sufficient precision. But its greatest trick is the wide turning angle due to the rear-wheel drive: The Twingo almost seems to turn on the spot. Formally, it's only 8.6 meters within which the French rascal turns.
Speaking of agility: The high agility is also contributed to by the low curb weight. For a fully electric vehicle, the Twingo is extremely light with an empty weight of 1,168 kilos and a total weight of 1,518 kilos, almost 300 kilos less than the Mini SE! The basis for this is a light and small battery, which weighs only 165 kilos net and undercuts its rivals in the small car segment with 21.4 kWh – naturally with corresponding implications for the CO2 footprint. Can you do something with such little capacity?
Efficient Drive: Around 12 kWh/100 km in the City
Indeed: Over our mixed city, countryside, and motorway round with a decent highway portion at the end, the electric vehicle consumed just 13.8 kWh/100 km, well below the unusually relevant factory specifications set by Renault at 17.2 kWh/100 km. The 270 kilometers in city operation should be very feasible, and the 190 kilometers in WLTP also sound realistic. Less so if you utilize the respectable 135 km/h top speed. Even on our tour, the dreary gray but easily readable bar reliably and linearly counted down the kilometers. Renault seems to have utilized all its E-expertise and implanted an efficient drive system into the microcar.
Another advantage of the small battery: Its energy reserve is quickly refilled, even without an expensive CCS system. Whereas Renault refers to a "Chameleon Charger" and means the system adopted from the Zoe, which handles 22 kW and 400 volts with the Type 2 connection. This means that at full charging power, the battery is back to 80% within an hour, and at 11 kW it takes a little more than twice as long. This seems quite practical and a not-so-bad way to keep costs under control.
Moderate Pricing, Good Availability
This brings us to another highlight of this smart and modern small car: The starting price is expected to be around 22,000 euros gross, likely even including the Easy Link multimedia system, which allows updates via over-the-air interface. The more stylish Vibes launch edition, which comes with various goodies such as nice seat covers, some exterior trim, and a decent sound system, starts at 25,666 euros gross. After deducting the manufacturer’s margin-reducing but sales-promoting premium rounded up to 10,000 euros, it’s not far from a combustion engine vehicle. But it far surpasses it in overall quality. Additionally, the manufacturer offers flexible financing starting at 109 euros per month, for a 24-month term, 15,000 kilometers total mileage, and a 2,150 euro down payment, with a takeover option and a final installment of 11,755 euros. Alternatively, you can return the vehicle or book a follow-up financing.
If Smart hadn't handed over this field with the Fourfour EQ, Renault would have had it to themselves for years with the Twingo.
Better late than never - and Renault also claims that the key to the Twingo Electric can be received as early as January from the order date today. Not every manufacturer can say that about their electric vehicles.
What Does This Mean?
This is how a Twingo should be — and how an electric car claiming environmental friendliness should be: small battery, light weight, efficient drive, compact and space-saving dimensions. While all claim to prioritize sustainability — the Teslas, Polestars, Audi e-trons, EQs, or I-Pace of this world — their oversized bodies and "lead-heavy" batteries, which consume an enormous amount of energy in production and also a vast array of critical raw materials, make this claim not very convincing. They are essentially the "rolling contradiction in terms" and a misstep at the start of the E-era.
We should use the entry into e-mobility for disarmament, for downsizing. Or simply revive the "good old" concept of a practical small car in an electric version. Just like Fiat does with the 500e or Renault with the Twingo Electric, or the VW group with the (unfortunately hopelessly out of stock) Up/Mii/Citigo iV trio. Both are likely to drain the water from EV start-ups like eGO from the start. But they also put a big question mark over pure LEV concepts like the Citroen Ami. Because the Twingo Electric is a "real," universal car, fully suitable for daily use and travel, with all the necessary comforts, sensationally affordable with the premium deduction. Let’s see how long the short delivery time lasts. Key-turning aside.
Translated automatically from German.Elektromobilität , Newsletter Elektromobilität , IAA Mobility , SUVs und Geländewagen , Hybrid , Antriebsarten, Kraftstoffe und Emissionen , Oberklasse- und Sportwagen , Carsharing , Autonomes Fahren (Straßenverkehr) , Ladeinfrastruktur , Verkehrspolitik , Formel E , Brennstoffzellen , Fahrzeug-Vernetzung und -Kommunikation , Fahrzeuge & Fuhrpark , Automotive-Messen & Veranstaltungen , Pkw, Kompakt- und Mittelklasse , Minis und Kleinwagen , E-Auto-Datenbank, E-Mobilität-/Automotive-Newsletter, E-Auto-Tests